Actually, given the label 'fruit' only really applies to edible stuff, spiky green inedible casing doesn't count a fruit. And edible seed without spiky green casing is a nut.
And using another language is cheating. We're talking in English at the moment, and defining what an olive is by English definitions. Which I'll freely admit may not be perfect, but according to English dictionaries, the olive is classed as a fruit.
And as for sweet - lemons aren't sweet, yet contain seeds. There's a Thai fruit (the name of which escapes me now) which trust me takes the word 'pungent' to heights you can't even imagine without experiencing it; it's so bad it's actually often banned on public transport, yet the Thais love it. But hey, they also eat cicadas... but anyway... it's not by any Western definition 'sweet' but it is a fruit. Because it contains seeds.
Seeing a pattern yet? :)
And if it's not in the food group 'fruit', what is it?
no subject
Date: 2003-06-02 02:38 pm (UTC)Actually, given the label 'fruit' only really applies to edible stuff, spiky green inedible casing doesn't count a fruit. And edible seed without spiky green casing is a nut.
And using another language is cheating. We're talking in English at the moment, and defining what an olive is by English definitions. Which I'll freely admit may not be perfect, but according to English dictionaries, the olive is classed as a fruit.
And as for sweet - lemons aren't sweet, yet contain seeds. There's a Thai fruit (the name of which escapes me now) which trust me takes the word 'pungent' to heights you can't even imagine without experiencing it; it's so bad it's actually often banned on public transport, yet the Thais love it. But hey, they also eat cicadas... but anyway... it's not by any Western definition 'sweet' but it is a fruit. Because it contains seeds.
Seeing a pattern yet? :)
And if it's not in the food group 'fruit', what is it?
no subject
Date: 2003-06-02 05:01 pm (UTC)Consider me beaten. :o)
I have no idea what category to put olives in.
hat are capers? Vegetables?
no subject
Date: 2003-06-03 03:47 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2003-06-03 09:54 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2003-06-03 09:54 am (UTC)What about tomatoes? I guess they're fruit, as are zucchinis and cucumbers.